Pular para o conteúdo principal

BRL


BRL and other brazilian assets have run quite a wild path last 4 years. From the “country of the future” to most hated EM and now to some “OK back to business”. No intention to tell the whole story again now once most know it very well. What calls my attention now is that perhaps once the excesses of the downside relative to other currencies has worked out it seems now for me that the optimism has also run its course in relative value to other EM's. Important to notice the “relative” because I still believe commodities has a way to go up so BRL will still benefit from it but Im concerned the “very cheap” is behind, both in relative value and also in fundamental terms.

Currency is probably one of the worst markets to predict. Besides many factors acting at the the same time they also change in importance during the time. Not to say that sometimes it seems no fundamental factor works at all. But sure tones of models can be made and at least we are not in the middle of nowhere without a compass.

Built this simple one below using only commodities and CDS. Chart is YoY % 




Not only not cheap but also a bit expensive.


On relative value against an equal weighted EM basket it also doesn't look very cheap anymore. 




Again, because I believe commodities still has a way up BRL should benefit, but the main point here its not a bargain it used to be at the beginning of the year, specially compared to other EM currencies.

Comentários

Postagens mais visitadas deste blog

It's no different this time...but the "timing"...

One of the biggest question (or the billion question) now is probably if the world and US is heading to a recession as the late cycle is not even a question any longer, as recent ECB and FED turn in monetary policy shows. After a few years of a synchronized global growth ( Link ) a very sharp deceleration in activity awoke markets and central banks late last years. To make things even scary in the market perspective the famous and widely watched 10 years minus 3 month US treasury curve went through the negative territory also (for the more optimists the 2Y x 10Y is still positive). If not big part of the problem trade wars certainly didn't help a late cycle economy but its hard to tell by how much. So this time is no different many would say. And they are right However (yes), the timing could be a bit different this time. First there are some signs of stabilization already on OECD composite leading indicators for Europe (who would guess that!!!) and china, with both impacting

What about the USD now?

Its no news that FX market is probably one the of the hardest to "predict". Maybe that's why I like it most, so I can be wrong very often and use this excuse..."its hard". Seriously, "predict" is not the perfect word to use for most of the financial assets because its a impossible task and carries a burden of a exact value, as many expect it to be. Instead, what is possible is to access all important variables and estimate the likely path, the odds,  levels and so on. Even so its nto easy, but we do it. We need to (at least to answer those friends and relatives that always ask "Should I buy USD now or later". I like to compare the FX market with weather forecast - now weather seems to be a more exact science!!!  We have longer term forecasts that has to do with cyclical factors like the 4 seasons. For the time horizon of weeks and months they measure pressure, currents, water temperature and many others to gauge what the weather will likely

BRL very expensive?

I read this news (link below) yesterday that indicates that BRL might be very expensive according to three models from Deutsche Bank. Though I don't have access to those models metrics, it got my attention because that information doesn't really fit very well with some simple models I run. I know there are lots of ways to model FX and as everyone might know its not a very easy market to figure out, specially for EM, where lots of feedback loops between country risk and FX rate happens and you can have long and short term models. Another point, specially for the PPP metric is the timeframe chosed. Anyway, just decided to post my findings here because they contrast with the DB picture. They might be right but here is my view: Business Insider (Australia) link for the news:  https://www.businessinsider.com.au/currency-valuations-september-deutsche-bank-2017-10 That's DB chart... My Behavioral model based on Commodities and CDS (YoY %) PPP metrics based on C